Marcie Colleen: My Main Character is Up a Tree, Now What? and GIVEAWAY

Three Tips for Generating a Satisfying Resolution

“The writer’s job is to get the main character up a tree, and then once they are up there, throw rocks at them.”
—Vladimir Nabokov

Now, I don’t consider myself a violent person.  I’m not a mean girl. And I don’t think I have ever—even in childhood—maliciously thrown a rock at someone.

MColleen_TreesHowever, hand me a work-in-progress and my pen and I will hurl, fling, and chuck stones of every size and shape at my main character. After all, as Nabokov says in the quote above, it’s my “job” as a writer. The problem is…my characters might not be as understanding.

You see, I have no issue coming up with obstacles and tension. In fact—and don’t tell my characters this—but I actually love turning the screws in this way. I delight in keeping the reader wondering “how will they ever get out of this?” but sometimes I, myself, am left wondering the same.

My problem lies in getting the main character back down from the tree. I mean, who would come down when you have a crazed curly-haired maniac lobbing boulders at your head?

If left in my “not-so-capable” hands, Curious George would still be frantically flying over the city holding on to a bunch of balloons, Wilbur would be wrought with depression upon Charlotte’s death, and Katniss and Peeta would be left squaring off with the task of killing one another to end the Hunger Games. These are all excellent climaxes, yet not good endings.  Something tells me that cliff hanger endings such as these should not occur in children’s literature.  Can you imagine the therapy sessions spawned by such bedtime tales?

So, a “writer’s job” also includes getting the main character back down from the tree and into a satisfying ending.  This is what I find to be the hardest part of plotting.

If you are a rock-chucker like me, here are my THREE tips to create a “climb down that tree, dear character” ending.


1. Get back to the basics. By basics, I mean your character and their traits. Remember this simple rule of good storytelling: everything your character needs to succeed should be revealed at the beginning.  Succeeding = getting out of the tree. So what is it about your character and their desires/goals that can be twisted into a satisfying ending?

The love and bond that Harry Potter had with his mother, even though separated by death, saves him from demise at the hands of Voldemort at the end of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone.

Katniss’s willingness to sacrifice herself for those she loves and her cunning ability to “pull one over” on the Capitol save the lives of both Katniss and Peeta in The Hunger Games.

And if Harold, of Purple Crayon fame, is creative enough to draw the very world he gets lost in, surely he can draw his way back to his own window using the moon he admired on the first page.


2. Make lemonade (or in this case, stone soup!) Your character may use the stones you threw at them to their advantage.  It’s a kind of cause-and-effect.

The peddler in Caps For Sale tries to get the monkeys to give back his caps, but all they do is mimic him.  Yet when he throws his own cap on the ground, the monkeys throw their caps onto the ground, too.

Each of Jonas’ revelations about his world provide the knowledge and strength needed to kidnap Gabriel and escape to Elsewhere in The Giver.

Think of each stone you have thrown as a tool that the character has gathered and then can use to defeat the conflict.


3. Brew up a storm. When all else fails, step away and just start a list of possibilities. A good creative brainstorm, whether alone or with others, can be exactly what you need.  Close the computer and grab a pen and paper.

Sometimes I am just a little too close to a character and just like them, I feel hopeless after all of that rock chucking.  The situation starts to look impossible to me, the writer, as well.  In those cases, I like to call in reinforcements and let others take a more distanced look at the tree.  I can’t tell you how many times I have had critique partners look at a story that abruptly ends at the climax and whine, “help me. I have no idea where to go from here!”

A quick note about brainstorming: Twyla Tharp, award-winning choreographer, often asks her students to generate a list of sixty possibilities to solve a problem and then chooses the sixty-first.  As she says in The Creative Habit, “The closer they get to the sixtieth idea, the more imaginative they become—because they have been forced to stretch their thinking. It’s the same arc every time: the first third of the ideas are obvious; the second third are more interesting; the final third show flair, insight, curiosity, even complexity.” So, keep those ideas coming. Challenge yourself. Dig deep.

You know that icebreaker game called the Human Knot? Everyone stands in a clump and grabs two hands within the group.  The goal is then to untangle the clump without losing hold of the two hands you grab. It’s a tough game, but it can be solved. Every time.

Think of your plot as this knot. It’s a knot that you created and therefore, you—along with your main character—have the tools and the creativity to solve the puzzle.  The answer shouldn’t be obvious to the reader.  And often, it won’t be obvious to you, the writer.  But it can be solved.  Every time.

Now let’s go chuck some rocks, shall we?


BOOKS RULE photo (1)

Marcie Colleen is a former classroom teacher turned picture book author. Her forthcoming picture books include The Adventure of the Penguinaut (Scholastic) and Love, Triangle (Balzer+Bray / HarperCollins). She is a frequent presenter at conferences for SCBWI, as well as a faculty member of Kidlit Writing School. Visit her on the web at

Marcie is giving away a picture book critique. If you are a registered Summer School student and would like a chance to win, please leave a comment on this post to be entered into the drawing. Good luck!

If you are registered for Kidlit Summer School, you can download a worksheet of Marcie’s writing exercise at our Exercise Book. This is a password-protected area — only members allowed! Please check your email for the password.


298 comments on “Marcie Colleen: My Main Character is Up a Tree, Now What? and GIVEAWAY

  1. Andrea Allen says:

    Great post – so much to think about – thanks for sharing and I can’t wait to read your books when they are available!


  2. Hi Marcie, great post! It came right on time. One of my characters is up a tree and I’ve been trying to figure out what to do. I can’t wait to re-think things and let him use the rocks I’ve hurled at him to get himself back down. Thanks again.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thank you so much for acknowledging the difficulty of getting characters back down from trees. I struggle with this too, and my local fire department is no help. 😉


  4. tinamcho says:

    Awesome post, Marcie! I love the analogy of the knots and more so, the quote from Twyla.


  5. mazziebee says:

    Solution 61 – scrunch up solutions 1 – 60 into balls and throw at characters in the tree. Let characters pick which one is best and get them to come down and discuss with you over a coffee/ glass of wine (depending on time of day). Thanks for the post Marcie – love the visuals – my head is now full of images of weird characters, holding hands in an odd barn dance formation, whilst trying not to get hit with metaphorical rocks!


  6. Awesome post! Wonderfully helpful examples.


  7. Margaret Greanias says:

    Always so insightful. Thank you for a great post. I love the creative brainstorm idea. Definitely using this for new (and old) stories!


  8. LauraHB says:

    Fantastic post! Thanks very much for your insights… so helpful!


  9. I’m ready, Marcie, to begin chunky some rocks and brainstorming at least sixty possilities. Thank you.
    ~Suzy Leopold


  10. Great ideas here! Thanks so much!


  11. Diane Nizlek says:

    Marcie, I love your story about Twyla Tharp and the 60 possibilities. and using that to remind ourselves to keep looking for that unique idea.


  12. donnacangelosi says:

    Thank you, Thank you, Thank you, Marcie! Fantastic ideas for rescuing protagonists who are stuck up trees.


  13. susanzonca says:

    I like the concept of inviting reinforcements to assist with the specific task of brainstorming ways to get the mc out of the tree. If they come up with the 60 ideas, then maybe I’ll be inspired to hatch the magical 61st.


  14. 61? I’ll give it a try….and hope the creativity flows 🙂


  15. The following quote from your lesson will be printed and and hung in my writing space. “Remember this simple rule of good storytelling: everything your character needs to succeed should be revealed at the beginning.”


  16. Michelle Leonard says:

    Ditto what Gail said! I just printed your tips. Awesome!!!


  17. You’ve given me just the tools I needed to move to the next stage in my draft. Brava! (and thank you)


  18. Lauri Meyers says:

    Marcie, fabulous post on a topic I don’t think I’ve seen in a blog post. Maybe this will get me out of the tree on a few mss. 🙂


  19. Heather L says:

    Marcie always has the BEST advice. Loved this!


  20. Debbie Vilardi says:

    If lemons make lemonade, perhaps rocks make a stairwell for climbing down. Fun!


  21. great post, Marcie – and the Human Knot is such a great example of tangledness that can be solved with some twisty turns and the guts to hang on. Good metaphor for writing….


  22. Cindy C. says:

    I think I’m still working on throwing the rocks, but I will keep in mind your advice for climbing down the tree. Thanks Marcie.


  23. ptnozell says:

    I laughed out loud, Marcie, as I pictured you at the base of the tree, rocks in hand, flinging at your characters. After reading your post, I realize that I need to fling more rocks & make sure I work on getting those characters back safely to the ground afterwards. Thanks for all of the great advice – and laughter!


  24. Rachel H says:

    Great post. I can use these tips!


  25. Dawn says:

    Love the idea of digging deep and challenging ourselves. Through brainstorming the possibilities are endless.


  26. Sue Fritz says:

    Thank you so much for your post!! I especially like your first tip!


  27. Susan Schade says:

    Great ideas here. Thanks for the advice!


  28. Great post. Your second tip is my favorite.


  29. writersideup says:

    Marcie, you’re amazing 🙂 Thanks so much on this advice on how to create a satisfying ending!


  30. writeknit says:

    I’m on my way out back to gather up a whole bucket of stone. Thanks for the inspiration 🙂


  31. Janet Smart says:

    Hmmm. I think I need to brainstorm and come up with that great 61st idea!


  32. MaDonna says:

    Love the idea about the 61st idea. It really is true that if one works and creates a list that long – something good will come out of it.


  33. Priya says:

    60 solutions? That’s gonna be a huge stretch for me but I’m likely to try. Thanks!


  34. julicaveny says:

    I love the analogies you’ve used! They all work for me! I really like the concept of “gathering the stones” and “the human knot.” My character will benefit from these suggestions and be a wiser, stronger girl in the end!


  35. bevbaird says:

    What wonderful advice! I tend to brainstorm til 9 or 10 – 61?? Will really have to stretch but so worth it in the end.


  36. kpbock says:

    Always love your advice, Marcie!


  37. Lee says:

    Thanks, Marcie for the incredible advice. I’m off to brainstorm now…61 is the lucky number! Your critique group is so lucky to have you on their side, cheering them on. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s